Allegations of Research Misconduct

RISTEC: Research in Information Systems and Technology

 
RESEARCH INTEGRITY

01 Allegations of Research Misconduct

RISTEC: Research in Information Systems and Technology takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously. The journal is committed to handling all credible concerns fairly, objectively, and confidentially to protect research integrity and the reliability of the scholarly record.

Types of Research Misconduct

Allegations may concern, but are not limited to, the following forms of potential misconduct:

  • Fabrication: Making up research data, results, or other research information.
  • Falsification: Manipulating research materials, methods, data, or results in a way that misrepresents the research findings.
  • Plagiarism: Using another person's words, ideas, data, figures, or other work without appropriate acknowledgment.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication: Republishing substantially similar work without appropriate disclosure.
  • Authorship misconduct: Misrepresenting authorship or failing to acknowledge contributions appropriately.
  • Ethical and publication violations: Misrepresenting ethical approval, permissions, competing interests, or manipulating the peer-review process.

Procedures for Handling Allegations

01. Receipt of Allegations

Allegations may be submitted by authors, reviewers, editors, readers, or other parties with relevant information. Reports should describe the concern clearly and include supporting evidence where available.

02. Initial Assessment

The editorial team will assess the nature and relevance of the allegation and determine whether further examination is warranted. The assessment will consider the information available and the seriousness of the concern.

03. Evidence and Clarification

Where necessary, the journal may request original data, research records, permissions, or other supporting documents. Relevant parties will be given a reasonable opportunity to provide explanations or responses. The journal may consult the authors' affiliated institutions or other appropriate bodies when necessary.

04. Evaluation and Decision

The editorial team will evaluate the available evidence impartially before determining an appropriate response. An allegation will not be treated as an established violation solely because it has been reported.

05. Appropriate Action

Depending on the findings and severity of the case, actions may include requesting further clarification, rejecting a manuscript, requesting corrections, publishing a correction or retraction notice, or referring the matter to an appropriate institution. Any action will be proportionate to the circumstances and intended to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.

Confidentiality and Fair Treatment

RISTEC will handle allegations with appropriate confidentiality and restrict access to case information to those who need it for the assessment. The journal will seek to avoid premature conclusions, protect the legitimate interests of the parties involved, and provide a fair opportunity for relevant parties to respond.

When a concern involves a member of the editorial team, appropriate arrangements should be made to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure impartial handling.

Reporting Research Misconduct

Reports concerning suspected research or publication misconduct may be submitted through the journal's official contact channels. Please provide a clear description of the concern and relevant supporting information where available.

Visit RISTEC Journal